The Medicaid Mandate is a multi-billion dollar burden on local business growth. Let’s fix it and lower county proper taxes 49%.
 

problem
Shockingly, New York is the only state in the nation that requires New York City and its 57 counties to pay a substantial portion of Medicaid — $7.6 billion, of which $2.2 billion is for counties outside New York City, and $5.4 billion for New York City.

The 63 counties of New York State are further handicapped by other State unfunded mandates – a haphazard patchwork of statutes and regulations the State requires the counties to fund. In addition, “…the state reduced its contribution to joint state/local expenditures, while it simultaneously reduced state Aid to Municipalities (AIM) funding, forcing localities to either increase property taxes or cut services” (Fiscal Policy Institute).

The result is that New York has the highest county property taxes in the nation, which drives businesses out of the state and stifles business growth. No other state comes close:

solution
 Medicaid

The State, as it did in the 1967 Constitutional Convention, must pass a constitutional amendment requiring the State to take over the costs of Medicare and ending all local shares.  Our specific suggestion is that the local share be phased out over 8 years, which means the state must find approximately $900 million per year out of its approximately $160 billion budget.

Currently, counties outside New York pay $2.2 billion per year in Medicare costs. Eliminating this requirement would mean a dramatic reduction in property taxes, particularly in Western New York:

The solution to raise the funds to eliminate the Medicaid mandate is not to cut benefits.  A dramatic decrease of 49.1% in local county property taxes may require a small increase in income taxes. However, properly done, the lowering of the county property tax will lead over time to local business growth and to significant increased revenue for the state.

Another possible idea would be former Lt. Gov Richard Ravitch’s suggestion (see below) that the state is disproportionally burdened, and should pursue a much higher percentage of reimbursement from the Federal Government than the low 50s it receives now. For instance, Oregon gets 73%, Michigan receives 69%, while Ohio gets 67%.

Other Mandates

In the new constitutional amendment, in addition to centralizing Medicaid, the State must also lighten the burden of other mandates as Oregon has:

Except as provided in list below, when the Legislative Assembly or any state agency requires any local government to establish a new program or provide an increased level of service for an existing program, the State of Oregon shall appropriate and allocate to the local government moneys sufficient to pay the ongoing, usual and reasonable costs of performing the mandated service or activity.

Taking a comprehensive approach to banning unfunded mandates would help stop Albany’s continued cost shift where the buck is continually passed onto the backs of local governments, school districts and taxpayers.  This would free up the counties to use the proceeds from their property tax to lower taxes on their citizens, invest in local services and grow their economies.

What do you think?

• Making the State pay the full cost would reduce county property taxes a whopping 49.1%!

• New York City spends 9% of its budget on Medicaid. Chicago, Los Angeles, Miami and the other major cities in the country pay nothing. By eliminating New York City’s unique Medicaid allocation, it will free up 5.4 billion dollars for other city initiatives.

Read More
top-300x481a
 

The New York State Constitution Does Not Mention Unfunded Mandates
 
 
top

Local Share for Medicaid

Local Share has an inglorious fifty-year history.

In 1966, Governor Rockfeller and the Legislature decided to allocate up to 50% of the State’s share to NYC and our counties.

The next year, the Democratic-controlled Constitutional Convention proposed:  “All Medicaid costs not paid for by the National Government will be borne by the State Budget.  There will be no local share.”  Unfortunately, the suggested new Constitution was voted down.

Read More

In addition to Oregon, as mentioned above, many states have constitutional or statutory restrictions on unfunded mandates:

  • 12 States have Constitutional Restrictions on Unfunded Mandates: AK, AL, CA, HI, LA, MA, MI, MO, NH, NJ, NM, TN
  • 11 States have Statutory Restrictions on Unfunded Mandates: CT, IA, IL, MT, NV, RI, SC, SD, VA, WA, WI
  • 4 States have Constitutional and Statutory Restrictions on Unfunded Mandates: CO, FL, ME, OR

Read More

learn
2016’s Property Taxes by State,” by John S Kiernan, WalletHub, March 7, 2016.

 

Alabama Unfunded Mandate Amendment 7,” Ballotpedia.

Counties Provide Roadmap To Unfunded Mandate Relief That Would Protect Taxpayers And Save Local Governments – Will Albany Have The Courage To Follow?” by Assembly Minority Leader Brian Kolb, September 7, 2012.

Fiscal Policy Institute Analysis of the Executive Budget,” Fiscal Policy Institute, February 7, 2017.

Lieutenant Governor’s Report on Controlling Increases in the Cost of New York Medicaid, by Richard Ravitch, September 20th, 2010.

Real and Permanent Mandate Relief,” New York State Association of Counties, December, 2015.

STOP Albany Coalition Launched to End Mandate Madness,” Westchestergov.com.

Unfunded New York State and Federal Mandates and Mandatory Reporting Requirements,” Valley Central School District.

comment